About this printable
Identify assumptions that connect evidence to a claim. The worksheet helps a reader ask what must be true for an argument to work.

What is on the page
The printable has eight entry rows with four labeled columns: Claim, Stated evidence, Assumption, Question. Two larger writing areas are labeled Argument and source and What would strengthen the reasoning. Use a short identifier in the name/project space and define the date or period covered before making entries. If you need another page, repeat that identifier and add a page number by hand so separate records can be read in order.
How to use it
Copy or paraphrase the claim accurately, then list the evidence actually supplied. State a possible unstated assumption and ask how it could be checked. Keep your own additions separate from the original argument.
Review and adapt the record
An assumption is not automatically false. Look for support, limits and alternative explanations before deciding how it affects the claim. This organizer supports critical reading and does not settle specialist factual disputes.
Before setting the page aside, read each entry as if you were returning to it next week. Replace an unclear abbreviation with a word or add a small key. Leave a field blank or write “not recorded” when information is unavailable; do not fill a gap with an invented detail. Use the two bottom prompts to summarize a decision or question that follows from the entries.
Download and printing instructions
Save the original high-resolution PNG with Download image beneath the printable. To create a PDF, select US Letter or A4 and use Download PDF. The website creates the PDF in your browser. Match the printer paper setting, keep uniform scaling and check that the title, table and bottom prompts are inside the print area. Print one test copy before making a set. This is a flat printable for handwriting, not an editable spreadsheet or a form that stores your entries. Original pages are for personal and classroom use; share the article link when recommending the resource.